| Platinum | Abruzzo Pizza |
| Gold | Pizza Nova |
| Silver | Regino's Pizza |
| Bronze | IL FORNELLO, Richmond Hill |
| Top Pick | Andolini's Modern Italian Market |
| Top Pick | IL Fornello Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Oak ridges pizza house |
| Top Pick | Papa Johns |
| Top Pick | Scaddabush |
| Top Pick | Vivo - Pizza & Pasta |